Penny Wong resets the agenda in New York – The Saturday Paper

Spread the love

More from
For subscription enquiries call 1800 077 514 or email [email protected]
Connect with us on
September 24 – 30, 2022  |  No. 418
September 24 – 30, 2022  |  No. 418
September 24 – 30, 2022  |  No. 418
It’s seven hours’ flying time from London to New York, but there is a huge chasm between the pageantry of a past empire on one side of the Atlantic and the 77th meeting of the United Nations General Assembly on the other.
Foreign Affairs Minister Penny Wong’s grim words belied the bright sunshine of her midweek news conference in the UN Plaza’s rose garden. “War in Europe,” she said, “has cast a shadow over this meeting.” 
Wong spoke of the “dreadful historic backdrop” for the assembly, channelling the very reason the organisation was established in the first place: to prevent a repeat of the catastrophe of World War II.
In contrast to the indifference of the previous government, Wong told the assembly that Australia believed the UN and its forums “need reinforcing”, especially as others “seek to undermine them”. The Foreign Affairs minister was accompanied by special envoy for reconciliation Pat Dodson and Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen, all with a mission to reset Australia’s international response to what UN Secretary-General António Guterres describes as “immense” tasks confronting the planet.
Guterres listed war, climate, the continuing pandemic, rising poverty and inequality. Those last points are where Pat Dodson comes in. The Aboriginal senator, who Wong introduced to the news conference as the “father of reconciliation”, had a series of high-level meetings progressing the Albanese government’s First Nations foreign policy.
Critical to this policy is the government’s commitment to right a historic wrong – the unrecognised, unceded sovereignty of the Australian continent by its original inhabitants. At his meetings, Dodson explained the Voice, Treaty, Truth process in these terms.
Midweek, he and Wong held a roundtable with the foreign ministers of Canada and New Zealand. Both nations have treaties with Indigenous people and Dodson says we have a lot to learn from “their adoption of Indigenous people’s rights”.
But this is no romantic enterprise. It is a hard-nosed acceptance that our record on human rights in regard to First Nations people is a threat to our security in the region and the world. Dodson found great encouragement at the UN for this broader acceptance of recognition and reconciliation. There was no quibble with his view that “putting self-determination at the heart of policy is a national security issue”.
Analysis by Huon Curtis of the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, a think tank more noted for being a hawk than a dove, puts it succinctly. He says: “Australia has a complicated and brutal postcolonial story and reckoning with this – demonstrating that we are learning, growing and strengthening democratic values – is a point of shared truth with other colonial nations. Forming a shared truth with our neighbours is a way for Australia to build trust, demonstrate shared values and exercise influence.”
Just as our record on climate change inaction has damaged our reputation in the region, so too has our record on relations with First Peoples. This is something China often reminds us of when we criticise its human rights record. But Curtis says the idea is not to absolve ourselves in tit-for-tat finger-pointing but rather to address the failures and remedy them.
Curtis has prepared reports for the Australian Defence Force on how to improve Indigenous relations as a way of enhancing social cohesion and boosting recruitment opportunities. He welcomes Defence Minister Richard Marles’ understanding of these values, in stark contrast to his predecessor, Peter Dutton, who dismissed them as “woke”.
The strategic policy analyst is enthusiastic for the Voice to Parliament. Curtis says the ability to hold governments to account, propose alternatives within political systems and strengthen avenues for deliberative participation are signs of democratic maturity. “The Voice,” Curtis says, “is a powerful step forward on that journey post empire.”
Wong says there are more than 270 ancestries now present in Australia. Almost half of the Australian population was born overseas or has a parent who was. She says this gives us a special entrée in foreign affairs. “Australia will be reflecting this rich character back to the world so the world can see itself in Australia.”
She adds: “The time has come for Australia’s full story to be told: our modern diversity and the rich heritage of First Nations peoples.”
To give flesh to this policy Wong called for expressions of interest for our inaugural ambassador for First Nations peoples to embed Indigenous perspective and experiences across the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. The ambassador will establish an office of Indigenous engagement in the department.
After 121 years of federated nationhood, we are playing catch-up with our founding reality that we have wilfully managed to repress. This was clear enough in the country’s approach to the funeral of Queen Elizabeth II, a pageant to an empire that historians say ended in 1971 when London withdrew its presence from “east of Suez”. Post-Brexit it is tentatively eyeing a comeback but, even so, it is a shadow of its former self and no longer “rules the waves”.
The royal funeral, with its battalions of magnificently uniformed military personnel, was a feast of colonial nostalgia, celebrating a time when the monarch’s forces were able to brutally impose their conquering will on the “natives” in Africa, Asia, the Americas and the Indo–Pacific.
Wiradjuri and Kamilaroi man Stan Grant gave us a searing insight into the pain and hurt this meant for his family – poverty, repression and discrimination. For the ABC, he wrote that he was sure he was “not alone among Indigenous people wrestling with swirling emotions. Among them has been anger. The choking asphyxiating anger at the suffering and injustice my people endure.” 
The funeral service was itself a captive of British history. It is probably not surprising that the obsequies for the governor of the Church of England would be a Christian service. But as the head of state of a multicultural, multifaith nation with its fair share of nonbelievers, there was exclusion. Only Christian leaders needed to apply to be part of the show.
At least in secular Australia, with no established church on Thursday, the belated memorial service was much more inclusive. But it was hard not to feel exhausted after two weeks of interminable adulation of Her Majesty the Queen. Australia will surely need to rethink this response when King Charles III goes to his eternal reward. There is no compelling reason why the memorial service could not have been held before the funeral and parliamentary eulogies given before the prime minister and governor-general flew to London.
The contrast with India could not have been greater. The Commonwealth’s largest member, celebrating 75 years of independence and 72 as a republic, held one day of mourning.
Pradeep Taneja of the Australia India Institute says Australia would be seen very differently in the world, especially in the Asia–Pacific, if we had a resident head of state. I remember a senior Japanese official putting this view to Australian journalists covering one of John Howard’s prime ministerial visits to Tokyo.
But if a string of opinion polls is any guide, Prime Minister Albanese’s studious deference to “Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth and her life of service” was in tune with majority opinion. Albanese’s approval rating continues to far outstrip that of the opposition leader, Peter Dutton, and anti-republic sentiment has surged.
This is not surprising. There is no official campaign and the prime minister is certainly not pushing it ahead of a referendum on the Voice. In one of his last interviews in Britain, however, Albanese was more forthcoming on the republic.
He said our constitutional arrangements “are matters of debate, of course, in Australia and certainly the royal family understands that”. Could that be a hint that the matter was actually raised in his meeting with the new king? More likely Charles knows Albanese’s republican sentiments and flagged a timetable to pursue them. Before rising to the throne, Charles took a keen interest in the sacking of the Whitlam government, doing nothing to dissuade the duplicitous governor-general John Kerr. In fact, he later praised Kerr for his “right and courageous” action.
Albanese didn’t demur when interviewer James Naughtie put to him that any nation considering its own history goes through a process of change and evaluation – and that process “is bound to continue, isn’t it?” The prime minister’s answer was a curt, “Of course that’s the case.”
But the prime minister missed a chance to appear more contemporary in his response to the Queen’s death, a view bolstered by our embarrassingly servile funerary ceremonies. It is one thing for the British to celebrate their history in a manner more akin to costume drama, but for a self-respecting nation on the other side of the world to follow suit is jarring.
Next week we are assured it’s back to the business of government. Thankfully, some of that work was already undertaken this week in New York by Penny Wong and her colleagues.
This article was first published in the print edition of The Saturday Paper on September 24, 2022 as “Part of death’s rich pageant”.
A free press is one you pay for. Now is the time to subscribe.
Share this article
Paul Bongiorno is a columnist for The Saturday Paper and a 30-year veteran of the Canberra Press Gallery.
Get the news you need
to your inbox.
This is a single use link for an unsubscribed friend to read this article.

September 24 – 30, 2022  |  No. 418
September 24 – 30, 2022 Edition No. 418
Exclusive: Cabinet documents show funding for new hospital staff refused Rick Morton
Dreyfus to review Morrison’s surveillance expansion Karen Middleton
Stalemate over rural fire fleet Bianca Nogrady
Refugees cut off from support Denham Sadler
The most important climate policy you’ve never heard of Mike Seccombe
Ukraine regains territory as Russia holds referendums Jonathan Pearlman
The news you missed since the Queen died Martin McKenzie-Murray
Penny Wong resets the agenda in New York Paul Bongiorno
Global warning on climate John Hewson
Letters & Editorial
Jon Kudelka cartoon, September 24 – 30, 2022 Jon Kudelka
Breaking the code
The house always wins
Writer Hua Hsu Leah Jing McIntosh
Pointing the cameras at Woodstock ’99 Sarah Krasnostein
Tiddas Yen-Rong Wong
Chalkface Cassie Tongue
Maya Newell Kate Holden
Eyes and teeth (Part 2) Anna Krien
Desi Girl: On feminism, race, faith and belonging Vyshnavee Wijekumar
The Pachinko Parlour Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen
Wildflowers Andy Jackson
Brined fish with lemon beurre blanc Annie Smithers
The rise and demise of pandemic puppies Elisabeth Knowles
Revisiting Tasmania’s Overland Track Kate Hennessy
The unravelling of Bulldogs star Tom Boyd Martin McKenzie-Murray
The Cryptic
Cryptic Crossword No. 418 Liam Runnalls
The Quiz
Is the Mona Lisa painted on wood or canvas? Cindy MacDonald
Already a subscriber? Log In
Latest in Opinion
letters September 24, 2022
The house always wins
If ever there were a salutary example of the corrupting power of money over integrity, it would be found within the grubby portals of the glittering gambling halls (Rick Morton, “Casino within a casino: Star’s extraordinary breaches” , September 17-…
editorial September 24, 2022
Breaking the code
Eddie Betts says there should be an investigation at every club in the AFL. “This could happen at any football club,” he says. “And I think that every football club should do a review like this. Every football club should come out and do an external review, contact the Indigenous players and past Indigenous players, and see how that footy club was.”
opinion September 24, 2022
The news you missed since the Queen died
Two weeks ago, on the day Queen Elizabeth II died , Steve Bannon surrendered himself to authorities. In the Solomon Islands, an election was delayed. In France, President Emmanuel Macron was embarrassed when people did not attend his unity…
environment September 24, 2022
Global warning on climate
The most significant failure of global leadership by governments in recent times is the failure to act decisively and as a matter of urgency on climate change. Surely we have moved beyond the ignorant and irresponsible mumbling of the climate…
letters September 17, 2022
Higher priorities
Mike Seccombe (Mike Seccombe, “ ‘I am hopeless now’: Australia’s $9.65 billion torture camps” , September 10-16) reminds us of the senseless crimes against humanity successive governments have committed against refugees, in our name. It’s time the…
economy September 17, 2022
Albanese’s budget reality check
As the government moves towards its first budget in October, uncertainties about our economic outlook are mounting. That’s partly because it is increasingly difficult to read the world economy, and there’s a growing belief that our interest rates…
View all in Opinion
View all editions
Take a stand
while sitting down.
Subscribe to The Saturday Paper
for less than $2.20 a week.
Get the news you need
to your inbox.
You’re not logged in. You can
Or subscribe here.

The Saturday Paper
More from Schwartz Media
Get the news you need to your inbox.
The Saturday Paper is a weekly newspaper,
published 50 times a year by Schwartz Media.
Phone  1800 077 514
Email   [email protected]
Email   [email protected]
© 2022 The Saturday Paper. All rights reserved.
By logging in you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy policy.
No Schwartz Media account? .
We’re here to help.
Email us at [email protected]
Freecall 1800 077 514 (Australia only)


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: